The Daily Journal

Idol - Webber

Posted 4/23/2008, 11:05AM, by TAhrens

Why do they do this to me every year?

Broadway tunes = yuck.

1) David C.

2) David A.

3) Syesha

4) Carly

5) Jason

6) Brooke

Who will go: Boy-girl-boy-girl-boy-girl …. Not this week. Brooke’s start-stop-start will cost her and she will be sent home.

Comments

I beg to differ….I think Jason’s lackluster performance will send him packing.

Posted by Kathie on 4/23/2008, at 12:21 pm

I think it will be brooke or Jason myself

Posted by kim on 4/23/2008, at 3:10 pm

I expected the bottom two to be Jason and Brooke. I have been ready for Brooke to go home since before the top 10.

Have to wonder if the vote for the worst vote is responsible for keeping her safe. She is now their pick since Kristy is gone to mess up the voting on IA.

Last night when they critiqued Brooke , I was surprised when Randy and Simon said stopping was the right thing to do. Paula was the only one who said it was a bad thing. When David A forgot the words to the Beatle’s song, they told him it was too late in the game to be doing that and that you should never let the audience know you messed up. So why is Brooke so special? LOL Also they acted like she never did this before-ummmmm she did it one other time too.

I am not a big Carly fan but I really thought she would be safe another weak. Since Jesus Christ SuperStar was one of my favorite

As far as Jason goes—he must have a really big fan base cause last night definitely was not his night.

Posted by Aunt Anita on 4/23/2008, at 9:47 pm

Syesha and Carly bottom two??? Carly gone?? Nooooo! I am so disappointed in the results. So shocked. It is not a charming contest it is a singing competition. Ugh. Just don’t know what to say.
The boy-girl-boy-girl pattern has ended.

Posted by John on 4/24/2008, at 8:45 am

I am irritated that Carly was sent home but I think we all knew she would be unjustly booted too early.

Posted by Jill on 4/24/2008, at 10:11 am

I tell ya, i was schocked beyond belief that Carly and Syesha were the bottom two! My opinon was the Jason and Brooke were the worst. Though Syesha isn’t always my favorite, she belted out a pitch perfect song on Tuesday, as did the two Davids. Carly also did an amazing job.
Jason with his dumb blonde side and Brooke with her whiny tearful side are really starting to get to me

Posted by kim on 4/24/2008, at 11:24 am

I agree with you Kim. I am so disgusted that I want to go and smack that silly smile right off that rat’s nest Jason’s stupid face! Carly has been robbed I tell you!

Posted by Kathie on 4/24/2008, at 3:13 pm

Post a Comment

All posts must first be reviewed before they will appear here.